Tuchel does the unthinkable: England to World Cup without Palmer, Foden or Trent

Some managers make squad lists. And some managers make declarations of principles. Thomas Tuchel has just announced England's squad for the 2026 World Cup, and what he's done isn't simply picked 26 players: it's sending a crystal-clear message about what kind of team he wants to take to North America.

The three names missing that explain everything

Cole Palmer. Phil Foden. Trent Alexander-Arnold. Three players who in any normal squad list from any English manager would be untouchable. All three staying home. Palmer was Chelsea's player of the year in 2024, but a groin injury and an inconsistent season have cost him his ticket. Foden was crucial at Euro 2024, but had less of an impact at City this year and Tuchel doesn't make excuses. And Trent Alexander-Arnold, one of the world's best fullbacks, capable of playing centrally as well. Out. Done. Tuchel has a clear vision of what his team looks like, and if you don't fit it, your name doesn't matter.

The surprising inclusions

Ivan Toney is the most eyebrow-raising. The striker has played exactly 7 minutes under Tuchel's watch. Seven. He's playing in Saudi Arabia. And yet, he's in the World Cup squad. Tuchel values his physical presence, his back-to-goal play, his ability to create in tight spaces. He's the number nine you want on the pitch in the 85th minute when you need a goal.

Noni Madueke (Arsenal) also comes in, bringing youth and directness. And then there's the Rashford case: the winger, who left Manchester United for Barcelona in the winter window, is also on the list. Which says a lot about the quality of England's squad — and perhaps something about United's level, that they sold a player who ends up getting called up for the World Cup wearing another shirt.

Can this England win the World Cup?

The million-pound question. They have Kane, who's been England's best striker for decades without winning anything with the national team. They have Bellingham, who can decide a match single-handedly. They have Rice and Saka in their prime. But without Foden or Palmer, they're missing that playmaker who, when things get blocked up, pulls out an impossible pass or an unexpected dribble.

Tuchel is betting on the team, on solidity, on collective work. It's German philosophy applied to the English national side. It could work. It could also end up being another "it's coming home" tournament that falls short. Football has that habit. And the English do too.

Frequently asked questions